The New York Yankees entered the offseason with high expectations. Meanwhile, rivals were busy making bold moves, and the silence from the Yankees was palpable. This lack of action is starting to test the patience of both fans and management.
As uncertainty looms over Cody Bellinger’s potential return, frustrations have only intensified. Once considered a hopeful solution, his re-signing now seems unlikely. When primary plans falter, the focus inevitably shifts inward. This transition can create tension.
On January 12, 2026, MLB analyst Cameron Maybin provided disconcerting insights into Jasson Domínguez’s future with the Yankees. He noted that if Bellinger is taken off the board, the organization might prioritize internal options, casting doubt on Domínguez’s role.
“The Yankees haven’t fully committed to allowing Dominguez to be the switch-hitter he’s always been.”
Maybin elaborated that Domínguez’s use in MLB has been inconsistent, raising questions about his ability to secure a full-time role in left field.
“With Bellinger out of the picture, there’s no guarantee Domínguez will secure the job.”
Instead, Maybin pointed out that a competitive dynamic may arise during spring training, pitting Domínguez against top prospect Spencer Jones for the left field spot.
Cody Bellinger Reality Check Forces Yankees to Rethink Their Offseason Approach
The New York Yankees are actively reassessing their strategy as their pursuit of Cody Bellinger diminishes. Internally, they have acknowledged the slim chances of signing him, particularly after Alex Bregman’s recent deal with the Cubs shifted market dynamics. With rising costs, adaptability is crucial.
Reports from January 12, 2026, indicate that the Yankees are now eyeing other players from the Chicago Cubs, in addition to monitoring Bo Bichette, who has garnered widespread interest across the league. If efforts to make external acquisitions stall, New York may need to cultivate talent already within their ranks. Although there’s no pressing deadline, establishing a clear direction is increasingly important.
