As the clock ticks down to the conclusion of the 2025 MLB season, Bo Bichette stands on the brink of free agency. The talented shortstop for the Toronto Blue Jays finds himself in a pivotal moment, not just for his current team but for his future in the league. While the Blue Jays are laser-focused on clinching the World Series, Bichette’s contract situation is emerging as a point of interest among fans and analysts alike.
Returning to the starting lineup has provided a much-needed boost for Toronto, especially during crucial matchups like those against the Los Angeles Dodgers. Yet alongside his on-field contributions, whispers of potential suitors for Bichette are gaining momentum, creating speculation about what his next contract might look like.
Toronto has recently solidified its long-term commitment to fellow star Vladimir Guerrero Jr., but expectations for Bichette’s contract appear more tempered. According to MLB insider Jim Bowden, a massive $500 million deal is unlikely, especially given Bichette’s defensive record. His skills at shortstop have been classified as below average, which could have a significant impact on his value as teams assess their options.
Bo Bichette had never played second base in MLB before tonight 🤯 pic.twitter.com/mFo9SQwLz7
— MLB (@MLB) October 25, 2025
“(Bichette is) a below-average defender at shortstop … and several interested teams view him as an option for third base going forward. His prime years have just begun, and he’s one of the youngest free agents on the market, though he has dealt with several lower-body injuries the past couple of years,” Bowden stated in an analysis shared through The Athletic.
Jim Bowden Puts $189 Million Price Tag On Bo Bichette’s Free Agency
Further analyzing the market, Jim Bowden has placed a price tag of around $189 million for a seven-year deal for Bichette. While this figure indicates a substantial contract, it is seen as relatively modest considering the current dynamics of MLB free agency, where top-tier players often command astronomical sums.
Bowden also referred to past injuries that have plagued Bichette, particularly those affecting his knee. These concerns may play a role for interested teams; however, Bowden expressed confidence that a healthy Bichette will attract numerous suitors. His versatility as a player — being considered for spots at shortstop, third base, or second base — only enhances his marketability.
The pressure is on for the Blue Jays as they gear up for Game 3 of the World Series against the Dodgers, who recently equalized the series after winning Game 2. Bichette’s performances will continue to be critical for the team’s ambitions as they strive for championship glory.
In conclusion, Bo Bichette’s upcoming free agency represents a complex interplay between his on-field performances, injury history, and the current market dynamics in Major League Baseball. As the postseason unfolds, all eyes will be on both his contributions to the Blue Jays’ playoff run and the broader implications for his future contract negotiations.
